>
Martin Carthy >
Songs >
Fair Maid on the Shore
>
Dave Swarbrick >
Songs >
Fair Maid on the Shore
>
Frankie Armstrong >
Songs >
Maid on the Shore
>
Eliza Carthy >
Songs >
Maid on the Shore
[Fair] Maid on the Shore / The Mermaid
[
Roud 181
; Laws K27
; Ballad Index LK27
; trad.]
Martin Carthy sang Fair Maid on the Shore in 1966 on his Second Album. A live recording with Dave Swarbrick at the Folkus Folk Club in the same year is available on Both Ears and the Tail. Frankie Armstrong sang this song as Maid on the Shore in 1972 on her LP Lovely on the Water; this track was re-released on the Topic theme CDs The Bird in the Bush: Traditional Songs of Love and Lust and Round Cape Horn: Traditional Songs of Sailors, Ships and the Sea.
Martin Carthy commented in his original recording's sleeve notes:
Bronson in his Tunes of the Child Ballads lists Fair Maid on the Shore as a variant on the Broomfield Hill theme, where a young girl extricates herself from a nasty predicament by employing a mixture of guile and magic. The story of a siren, whether benevolent, malevolent or just plain amoral, is quite widely diffused in Europe but is not so common in England. Learned originally from the vast repertoire of A. L. Lloyd.
and Lloyd noted in the sleeve notes of The Bird in the Bush on Frankie Armstrong's version:
Another girl trickster, but this time perhaps she's no ordinary girl at all. Seemingly at the mercy of a crew of rough sailors, she extricates herself with such aplomb that it's no wonder some country folk call the song The Mermaid. The evocation of moonlight through the song seems to emphasise a supernatural atmosphere, though the delicate wit of it keeps the song's feet on the ground.
The Maid on the Shore was also sung by Cyril Tawney on his CD Nautical Tawney: Songs of the Old Seafarers from which Eliza Carthy learned it and recorded it with the Ratcatchers (Jon Boden, Ben Ivitsky, and John Spiers) for her 2005 album Rough Music. She commented further:
Girls have always fancied that the sound of their voice could possibly lull a man, or perhaps a forest full of enchanted creatures, into doing exactly what they want. But perhaps she really is magic. Songs where the hero or heroine tricks someone, fools him of her into falling in love or getting into a compromising position are quite common. Doesn't seem very nice, but it's true, and the tradition can be seen carrying on to this day in hilarious adverts for cleaning products.
This is a video of Eliza Carthy and the Ratcatchers playing Maid on the Shore at Buxton Opera House in 2007:
Rachael McShane sang Maid on the Shore in 2009 on her CD No Man's Fool.
Jon Boden sang Maid on the Shore to Frankie Armstrong's tune (instead of the above Ratcatchers' version) as the March 29, 2011 entry of his project A Folk Song a Day.
Lyrics
| Martin Carthy sings Fair Maid on the Shore | Frankie Armstrong sings Maid on the Shore |
|---|---|
|
Oh it's of a sea captain who sailed the salt sea |
Well it's of a sea captain who sailed the salt sea |
|
“Well I have got silver and I have got gold | |
|
So the sailors all got in the very long boat |
So the sailors they got them a very long boat |
|
Now it's with much persuasion they got her on board |
With much persuading they got her on board |
|
And when they've arrived alongside of the ship |
And when they arrive alongside of the ship |
|
“Oh thank you, oh thank you,” this young girl she cried, |
“Oh thank you, oh thank you,” this young girl she cried, |
|
So she sat herself down in the stern of the ship |
She sat herself down in the stern of the ship |
|
And she's robbed them of silver, she's robbed them of gold, |
And she robbed 'em of silver, she robbed 'em of gold, |
|
“Oh were my men drunk or were my men mad |
“Oh were my men drunk or were my men mad |
|
“Now your men were not drunk and your men were not mad |
“Now your men they weren't drunk and your men they weren't mad |
| Eliza Carthy sings Maid on the Shore | Rachael McShane sings Maid on the Shore |
|
There was a young maiden who lived all alone, |
It's of a fair maiden who walked all alone, |
|
There was a young captain who sailed the salt sea, |
It's of a sea captain who sailed a fine ship, |
|
“I've got lots of silver, I've got lots of gold, |
This captain had silver and this captain had gold, |
|
So with long persuading they got her on board, |
After many persuasions they got her on board, |
|
The night being so still and the water so calm, |
“I will sing you a song,” this young maiden did cry, |
|
Then she robbed him of silver, she robbed him of gold, |
Then she's robbed them of silver, she's robbed them of gold, |
|
“Well, were my men stupid or were my men drunk |
The captain was mad and the captain was sad, |
|
“No, your men they weren't stupid, your men they weren't drunk, |
“Now your men must be mad and your men must be sad, |
Acknowledgements
Martin Carthy's version transcribed by Garry Gillard and Reinhard Zierke. Thanks to Roberto Campo and Uilm Abruzzo for transcribing from Eliza Carthy's singing.
